Sikh intellectual Prof. Sarchand Singh Khiala sharply criticized Acting Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Kuldeep Singh Gargajj for ordering Gurdwara Shaheed Ganj Sahib manager Jatinderpal Singh—under whose watch the anti-Gurmat act of distributing stamped “Baba Deep Singh Ji Treasury” currency notes occurred—to investigate the incident.
Inquiry Flaws
Khiala called it childish and illogical, violating natural justice by tasking a suspect with self-probe, risking truth suppression over revelation. He stressed Akal Takht’s orders set historical precedents, demanding wisdom—not casual rulings undermining its sanctity.
Sikh Principles
Jathedar rightly deemed the “Sevak Jatha Ishnan” practice manmat, with no historical precedent for Gurdwara cash handouts; Granthi Giani Daya Singh confirmed the true Guru’s treasury is Naam, Gurbani, seva—not notes. Khiala urged an independent high-level panel of scholars, lawyers, and officials, tracing the custom to nearby Baba Deep Singh site.
Community Call
He warned against superstition-mongers exploiting Gurdwara names for gain, citing unresolved 328 saroop disappearances and media curbs; Sikh Sangat must report manmat promptly to uphold Panthic decorum.
